Comparative Test: 9 ink All-in-Ones up to 200 Euros
von Florian Heise
übersetzt von Ulrich Junker
Erschienen am 20. Mai 2011 bei Druckerchannel.de, 18 Seite(n)
https://www.druckerchannel.de/artikel.php?ID=3004
Print speed: Text, photos, graphics
The most frequent print job is the output of a single page. So the time this takes is important.
And to test print speed under real-life-conditions, the lab uses a 10-page document as well.
In addition we test the print speed for a photo and a page with graphics.
Print speed: Text
We use two documents for that:
- ISO 10561, Dr. Grauert: A simple one-side text without graphics. This is used to test FPO (first page out) and copy speed (fastest print speed possible).
- Ten-page business document: 10 pages with text, a company logo, a table, and a pie chart. It is sent to the printers in three modes: Fast mode (draft), normal mode (no change in the drivers), and quality mode.
Dr.-Grauert: Test document ISO 10561.
FPO - first page out
The most frequent print job for a basic printer or AIO is the output of a single page. So the time this takes is important.
Copy-mode
The lab sends one page (Dr. Grauert, ISO 10561) to each printer, demanding eleven copies. After the first page is in the output bin, timing begins, and ends, when the last page is printed.
Copy-mode informs you about maximum print speed possible under ideal conditions.
For FPO all AIOs are sufficiently fast, except for the Epsons. In copy mode, however, the Epsons excel, just the Canons are pretty slow here.
| Comparison of print speeds | ||
|---|---|---|
| FPO | Copy mode | |
| HP Officejet 6500A E710a | 9 sec. | 18,2 ppm |
| Epson Stylus SX620FW | 10 sec. | 18,8 ppm |
| Epson Stylus Office BX525WD | 12 sec. | 18,8 ppm |
| Lexmark Prospect Pro205 | 14 sec. | 16,7 ppm |
| Canon Pixma MG5250 | 14 sec. | 12,5 ppm |
| Canon Pixma MG5150 | 14 sec. | 11 ppm |
| HP Photosmart Plus B210a | 15 sec. | 18,2 ppm |
| Brother DCP-J515W | 28 sec. | 14,6 ppm |
| Brother MFC-J615W | 28 sec. | 14,6 ppm |
| Copyright Druckerchannel.de | ||
Ten-page business document
To test print speed under real-life-conditions the lab uses a 10-page document, which is sent to the printers in three modes: Fast mode (draft), normal mode (no change in the drivers), and quality mode.
The Epson AIOs with their high speed of print do very well in this test. HP is a bit slower. Brother and Canon are noticably slower.
| Speed: Ten-page business document | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| Fast print | Normal print | Quality print | |
| Epson Stylus Office BX525WD | 14,3 ppm | 10 ppm | 1,6 ppm |
| Epson Stylus SX620FW | 14,6 ppm | 9,1 ppm | 1,6 ppm |
| Canon Pixma MG5250 | 10 ppm | 7,1 ppm | 1,6 ppm |
| HP Officejet 6500A E710a | 13 ppm | 6,7 ppm | 1,8 ppm |
| HP Photosmart Plus B210a | 12,2 ppm | 6,7 ppm | 1,5 ppm |
| Lexmark Prospect Pro205 | 12,5 ppm | 6,1 ppm | 2,1 ppm |
| Canon Pixma MG5150 | 6,8 ppm | 5,7 ppm | 1,1 ppm |
| Brother DCP-J515W | 12,2 ppm | 2,9 ppm | 1,1 ppm |
| Brother MFC-J615W | 12 ppm | 2,8 ppm | 1,1 ppm |
| Copyright Druckerchannel.de | |||
Print speed: Photo and graphic print
Print speed for a high-quality photo in A4 on photo paper is tested using the photo below (left side).
Speed of graphic print is tested with an A4 graphic (below, right side), using ink-jet paper the manufacturer recommends. The drivers are set to highest quality.
Both files are available here: DC Testfiles.
Lexmark excels in this test. Only Canons Pixma MG5250 comes near their speed when printing a photo. Allow some extra time if you print photos and graphics with Canons MG5150.
| Print speed: Photo and graphic | ||
|---|---|---|
| DC A4-photo | DC A4-grafic | |
| Lexmark Prospect Pro205 | 1:53 min | 1:07 min |
| Canon Pixma MG5250 | 1:56 min | 3:26 min |
| Epson Stylus Office BX525WD | 2:41 min | 1:31 min |
| Epson Stylus SX620FW | 2:42 min | 1:24 min |
| HP Photosmart Plus B210a | 2:47 min | 2:21 min |
| HP Officejet 6500A E710a | 3:44 min | 2:16 min |
| Brother MFC-J615W | 3:50 min | 2:09 min |
| Canon Pixma MG5150 | 4:00 min | 6:40 min |
| Brother DCP-J515W | 4:30 min | 2:18 min |
| Copyright Druckerchannel.de | ||
Seamless postcard
We determine print speed for a photo, 10x15 cm, seamless, on photo paper.
The seamless print speed results in the same ranking order as in our test with an A4 photo.
| Print speed: Seamless print | |
|---|---|
| 10x15-photo | |
| Lexmark Prospect Pro205 | 0:52 min |
| Canon Pixma MG5250 | 1:00 min |
| Epson Stylus SX620FW | 1:14 min |
| HP Photosmart Plus B210a | 1:16 min |
| Epson Stylus Office BX525WD | 1:18 min |
| HP Officejet 6500A E710a | 1:20 min |
| Brother MFC-J615W | 1:45 min |
| Canon Pixma MG5150 | 1:45 min |
| Brother DCP-J515W | 3:07 min |
| Copyright Druckerchannel.de | |